Dependency Injection – Keep your privates to yourself

Jacob Proffitt has hit the nail on the head with his “I do wish that people would admit that DI doesn’t have compelling applicability outside of Unit Testing” post, the discussion continues with Nate Kohari response post and Jacobs counter post. Oren has also joined in with two posts.

Here a some ideas for you to think about.

DI as a Silver Bullet – You lose power

When you use DI as a ‘Silver Bullet’ you are losing more then half the abilities of your programming language. You can not use static methods or the ‘new‘ keyword or sealed types. Oh, you have to make all your methods virtual too. This is going to be even harder once Extension Methods (and Linq) become main stream.

Code to Enable Change – Costs More

Creating Code that is there only to “Enable Change” has a big “YAGNI” written all over it. (Making the code more complex and thus wasting time in development and then in maintenance, for a chance that it will be used in the future). We have understood that this is the wrong plan ages ago. We now know that we can not predict the future and it is best to change our code only when we need to (a process called refactoring).

Keep your Privates to Yourself

Jacob, you are quite right about DI coming into fashion only because the tools where not good enough. DI does have other applications outside testing, but it is being overused in most application only to make the code testable.

One of the first issues that was discussed when TDD was starting was: “should we change our code to make it testable?”
Should we change the visibility of our code?
Should we change the design of our code?
This lead to a collision between testable code and OO encapsulation. Developers started to expose private parts of the code to enable testing. It started with private fields and methods and now it is the complete design. This collision still exists when using inadequate tools, but with the right tools, you can enjoy the best of both worlds.

Get the Best Tools to get the Job Done

Thousands of developers have understood this and have started testing there code without being forced to use a specific pattern required by some tools. Many development shops, didn’t test their code because of the testability/design collision. With the right tools they now understand and test their code.

As Joel Says: “Get the best tools“

August 19, 2007 Eli Lopian .NET Tests , TDD 417 Comments
417 comments
  1. Pingback: Dependency Injection - Good for more than just unit testing. : Mostly Progamming Stuff
  2. Pingback: 依赖注入是否值得？ - 自由、创新、研究、探索…… - 博客园
  3. Pingback: Poking Bears - Jacob Proffitt

  16. FOLLOW THE STAR-LEDGER: | ralph lauren New Zealand and Sri Lanka meet in the opening World Cup match in Christchurch on Feb. 14. z http://www.hollister.in.net
    An article in the Star the following day confirmed that Jack T. Ryan died of his injuries, but offered nothing new on the feud.聽 michael kors outlet online Thomas, who played the Palmer course, said the wind 鈥渨asn鈥檛 really in a consistent direction the entire day. It was supposed to be northwest or north-northwest and it just kept swirling a lot.鈥?
    In 1984, Bruce Springsteen’s song “Born in the U.S.A.,” written from the point of view of a contemptuous Vietnam veteran in a dead-end world, found itself celebrated for its rousing chorus. coach outlet store online Meryl Streep extends her lead as the most nominated performer with 19, thanks to Rob Marshall s Into the Woods. b gucci
    Everyone knows rice is a stellar side and main锟絙ut it also can lend a quite fantastic flavor to dessert.锟絋his warm pudding staring dried cherries and toasted almonds has a surprisingly velvety texture. http://www.moncleroutlet.us.org PALM HARBOR 聳 The Palm Harbor Chamber of Commerce and residents will honor survivors and casualties of the surprise attack that brought the United States into World War II on Dec. 7.
    p Football europ茅en, mythe ou r茅alit茅 ? gucci outlet online “I make up my own chords and stuff like that but I鈥檝e not really written anything yet. I do go on the Playstation from time to time but find there’s nothing better than a bit of strumming or listening to music to relax. tory burch outlet online
    – Jamarius Henderson finished his high school career on a high note. toms shoes outlet Share http://www.tomsoutlet.us.org
    State police Lt. Richard L. Krawetz, the trial s first witness, testified that when police showed up at the property, Selenski laughed. coach outlet There are high utilizers who are well off and well insured, of course, but many are uninsured or underinsured people who use the emergency department as their sole source of health care. n abercrombie kids
    鈥淎HCCCS鈥?provider payment rates are so low, you don鈥檛 get a lot of private practice groups that want to go work in those areas,鈥?she said. That makes these communities dependent on nonprofit groups and community health centers. burberry outlet online MOPS (Mothers of
    Article published on Tuesday, Dec. 23, 2014 hollister clothing SHOREWOOD INVITATIONAL
    During his five seasons as a head coach, Mangini s teams never had a defense that ranked among the top 15 in terms of yards allowed. His 2006 Jets ranked 20th in yards allowed while giving up the sixth-fewest points. Mangini went 23-26 with the Jets, 10-22 with the Browns. tory burch outlet Medjool Dates: One of the sweetest fruits on the planet, tender Medjool dates are available in most super- markets now.
    It didn’t help the Quakes to lose their leading scorer for the World Cup this summer. The simple fact is San Jose has not had a consistent starting lineup because of ill-timed injuries. The Quakes entered an unforgiving stretch missing four of their best offensive players and U.S. national team defender Clarence Goodson. oakley 鈥淟isten to fast music if you like to be pumped up, or calm music if you are getting too nervous and you want to calm down.I do listen to music, probably more than I used to. When I started running I鈥檇 have to carry a WalkMan, but now it鈥檚 a bit easier.
    n rebounds against Tennessee on Feb. 20, and 15 points and nine rebounds against polo The much awaited census of Northern Cyprus will start on 4th December. The census was supposed to be conducted in October. The census will structured by the State Planning organization.
    Twitter’s challenge brings that battle to the modern era, allowing the court to decide “whether government’s need for secrecy survives a First Amendment review,” Opsahl said. af Democrat: 35% l http://www.louisvuittonhandbags.mobi
    Friday’s announcement is expected to help the company and the universities as they attempt to recruit a Johnson Controls-endowed energy storage professor at UW-Milwaukee and Madison. toms shoes outlet “That was a championship game,” said Seahawks coach Pete Carroll.
    b Fees: Free. lv bags Follow Craig Gilbert on Twitter x
    鈥?Use a broker: Just as you would use a real estate broker or agent to guide you through the purchase of a home, consider relying on a franchise broker when buying a franchise. A broker can guide you through the selection process and can help you avoid certain risks.聽 As an expert in franchise documents, he or she can save you considerable time and confusion. michael kors outlet (Inman) http://www.michaelkors.co.com
    ciBjb25kaXRpb25lcnMgYW5kIGJvZHkgd2FzaGVzLiBUaGV5IGNhbiBjb250YWluIHByZXNlcnZh coach outlet online I didn’t necessarily have the desire to do it full time, said Lause, who graduated with a degree in chemistry and a minor in business. Once I started to get competition online, I got this entrepreneur blood going. m michael kors
    A similar struggle will also be gong on in Congress. Sen. Dianne Feinstein announced after the Newtown massacre that she would introduce a bill to impose a new assault-weapons ban, and . However, gun-rights groups are mobilizing their supporters to fight the bill. coach outlet online Eroglu and Christofias will together attend the opening ceremony of the Yesilirmak crossing point in the northeast of Cyprus.North Cyprus leader and South Cyprus leader together will open a new passage point in the northwest of the Cyprus.The link is named as Yesilirmak crossing point which will connect parts of TRNC and Greek Cyprus.United Nations Peace Keeping Force (UNFICYP) said that the opening ceremony of this passage will take place on 14th October.Turkish Cypriot President Dervis Eroglu, Greek Cypriot leader Demetris Christofias, EU’s Enlargement Commissioner Stefan Fuele, Special Adviser to UN Secretary-General on Cyprus Alexander Downer and Frank Urbancic, the U.S. ambassador in the island will take part in the opening ceremony of the crossing point.Eroglu and Christofias will give their speeches at the opening ceremony and will visit the nearby villages of both the sides of the crossing points
    A lot of reports are already online and thanks to live-streaming, you no longer need a golden ticket to hear the discussions. hollister clothing store That’s the way it’s been the whole year, Capers said. That’s one of the most gratifying things about this team, because nobody has used it as an excuse. When guys have gone down, we come in and say, ‘Who’s got it to win and who’s going to go in there and play?’ x michael kors outlet online
    They may be tasty, but mixed drinks made with sugary syrups are laden with empty calories. Skip the eggnog and the madori sour, and instead choose from a wide array of wines and light beers. You ll get your holiday buzz without breaking the calorie bank! http://www.coachoutlet.cc (510) 251-0329

  21. We do have recourses, filing a good deal legal profession on their own roles in setting these rates that are
    debilitating and was put in place. If you have chosen should have to find a solution. The file was a declaration. There’s no
    legal profession such thing after a matrimonial rupture is to spend money for the bogus vaccine autism study?

    I take it as larger than all other major shooting school
    that a legal claim. This is a” pre-grant opposition”.

  22. Gone are the days of one way marketing or merely just posting comments about
    your site or other related topics. Two: Research
    different services – Assuming that you are going to hire someone to do
    it for you, the next step is to research as many different
    services as possible. But in general here are
    the services that an online business owner should expect from dc seo (Herbert) experts and
    other agencies and consultants:. A guy named Alan Emtage, a student at the University of Mc – Gill,
    developed the first search engine for the Internet in 1990.

  23. Get testimonials from the clients you already worked with,
    about your work and experiences. The process of SEO is the series of steps that are undertaken to ensure that a website
    is visible among internet users to an optimal level.
    While effective dc seo needn’t be difficult, it does take
    work. Webmaster follows a long process to promote a website in top search engines (Google, Yahoo and Bing).

  24. Another major difference between the two is that while PPC
    is a paid form of advertising, organic search engine optimization is absolutely free.
    The trends in this industry change and new developments take place only
    when Google comes up with some novel feature that ends up breaking every site’s SEO and compels them to consider a change in their current content presentation in order
    to do well. Forgetting to write for an audience is one of the biggest mistakes that bloggers make.

    There are two techniques that combine to form a complete
    dc seo (Serena).

  25. Gone are the days of one way marketing or merely just posting comments about your site or other related topics.
    The trends in this industry change and new
    developments take place only when Google comes up with some novel feature that ends up breaking every site’s dc seo [Grazyna] and compels them to consider a
    change in their current content presentation in order to
    do well. Unlike TV, radio and other traditional marketing channels
    that need big budgets to be effective, SEO can be cost effective.
    In this way, it is informed about the kind
    of information that a surfer is looking for.

  26. Get testimonials from the clients you already worked with, about your work
    and experiences. Any business to conduct business on the web should have a web site
    created especially for creating an awareness of their products and
    ser-vices to the planet at large. Auro – IN has a strong team that is built on the delivery of
    outstanding campaign results, customer service and appreciation, and high levels of technical capabilities and values.
    There are two techniques that combine to form a complete dc seo (Thomas).

  27. Nowadays, the conditions homes for sale bethesda maryland
    – Meghan,
    your website to be ranked high in the search engine results are based on the search engine optimization techniques that you decide to use.
    The usual SEO methods include keyword research, link building and such.
    Unlike TV, radio and other traditional marketing channels that need big budgets to be effective, SEO
    can be cost effective. Further the sites whose ranking using the search engines
    is good will attract potential clients, which results to mores sales.

  28. Although being aware of keyword percentages is a
    good idea, it is more important that content be relevant and useful to the visitor.
    The Internet has changed the way we attain information forever and Google has been the main driving force and proponent behind this instant access to information.
    Auro – IN has a strong team that is built on the delivery of outstanding campaign results, customer service and appreciation, and high levels of technical capabilities and
    values. There are two techniques that combine to form
    a complete dc seo.

  38. This undoubtedly qualifies together, although it’s so difficult to find important information nowadays.

    Departing can undoubtedly come back soon and pleased!

  39. Each of them has a different function according to the intensity of the misspelled
    keywords. Thirdly, the search engines need legit companies
    to do web site; Leonardo, optimization. Unlike TV, radio
    and other traditional marketing channels that need big budgets to be effective,
    SEO can be cost effective. There are two techniques that combine to form a
    complete SEO.

  42. I love reading blogs similar to this! Causes me to experience a feeling that is warm satisfying and in addition enlightened!
    Thank you so much!

  46. magnificent pսt up, νery informative. &#8544 ponder why tҺе ߋther
    specialists οf tҺіs sector dߋ not notice tɦіѕ.
    Үߋu must continuee үour writing.

    Ι’m sure, уоu’vе ɑ
    great readers’ base already!

    Vsit mу blog: blast email

  47. Hі! Ι just wanteɗ tο
    ɑsk if yߋu eνеr ɦave аny issues &#7457ith hackers?

    Mу &#8572ast blog (wordpress) ѡаѕ hacked аnd
    Ӏ &#6513nded u&#11427 losing months оf hard ԝork ɗue t&#1086 no
    data backup. Ɗο уߋu Һave ɑny methods
    tο stop hackers?

  49. hello!,I like your writing so a lot! share we keep up a correspondence more about your article on AOL?
    I require a specialist on this space to unravel my problem.

    May be that is you! Looking forward to see you.

Add Comment

Required fields are marked *. Your email address will not be published.